Gary Neville says Man Utd need a goalkeeper, but would Emi Martinez or Gianluigi Donnarumma fit?

Sky Sports' Gary Neville says Manchester United 'unequivocally' need a new goalkeeper despite Ruben Amorim's defence of No 2 Altay Bayindir after his error led to Arsenal's 1-0 win on Super Sunday.

The stopper replaced formerly regular first choice Andre Onana - who was not in the match squad - but failed to stop a Declan Rice cross that was then nodded home by Riccardo Calafiori.

Despite an improved attacking performance from Man Utd, they were unable to answer the 13th-minute strike, with Arsenal goalkeeper David Raya given the player of the match award by Neville.

• Man Utd 0-1 Arsenal - Match report and highlights
• Hits and misses: Matheus Cunha and Bryan Mbeumo give Man Utd hope in defeat
• As it happened | Teams | Match stats
• Watch Premier League highlights for free

The game highlighted the difference in quality of goalkeepers between the two sides, and the former Man Utd defender is adamant that Ruben Amorim must sign a new stopper.

On the Gary Neville Podcast, he said: "There's a glaring issue that Man Utd cannot ignore and it is the fact they need to find a goalkeeper.

"They have to. I'm unequivocal on that because I had an experience with Man Utd for 20 years where there were two big periods of seven or eight years with Peter Schmeichel and Edwin van der Sar.

"In between, we had seven or eight goalkeepers in a six, seven, eight-year period and it is really unsettling when you haven't got a dominant No 1, who is dominant in the air, who owns his six-yard box, comes and punches everything and makes a lot of saves to win you points when your defenders make mistakes.

"I don't know where they are on PSR, but they might have to magic up a bit more money in the next week or two, or do something on loan.

"The two that have been mentioned in the last two weeks have been Emi Martinez and [Gianluigi] Donnarumma.

"The reason I think they would be good goalkeepers for Man Utd is not necessarily because they are the best goalkeepers in Europe, but they are big personalities and characters.

"You've seen Donnarumma in a European final save those penalties for Italy. He looked like a giant. He's played for PSG in huge games under pressure. Martinez has played in the World Cup final and won it for Argentina.

"They have played under extreme pressure and they almost walk out with that arrogance and dominance of a goalkeeper - Man Utd need that.

"There are a number of things Man Utd need this season and Amorim is getting to that point now where he thinks he's got a team that could do something.

"However, they need to sort the goalkeeper because they concede goals and lose points, and it continually undermines what you are doing.

"When the goalkeeper is flapping at the ball, those 72,000 home fans are groaning and that sends a shiver through the spines of defenders. It also sends a shiver through the goalkeeper and creates an anxiety around the stadium.

"You've got to have personality, stability and character in that position, and Man Utd are going to have to deal with it in the next couple of weeks."

Amorim not drawn on possible new goalkeepers

Man Utd boss Amorim also has veteran goalkeeper Tom Heaton at his disposal, but would not be drawn on whether he is looking to sign another stopper before the end of the transfer window.

He told Sky Sports: "We have players to win any Premier League game.

"We need to focus and forget about the noise. We're fighting for places and that's a good thing. It doesn't matter who is playing, we want to win games."

• Got Sky? Watch PL games LIVE on your phone?
• Not got Sky? Get Sky Sports or stream with no contract on NOW?

Reflecting on the goal, the coach defended Bayindir, adding: "[It was] more or less the same thing that happened at times last season.

"For me, it's not playing the ball, it's protecting the guys they're attacking. I understand that we want goals but when you're touching the goalkeeper in that way, I think it's hard. To lose with a goal like this is hard.

"It's hard to be strong when you have to push and go for the ball. Sometimes you are pushing and you don't have more hands to go for the ball.

"We need to be stronger in that moment, but we need to do the same thing in the opposite side. We have to adapt to the rules and today, it's hard to accept because we were the better team."

Amorim continued his defence of Bayindir and his goalkeepers in his post-match press conference.

"He suffered a goal like this where? Against Tottenham? It was without VAR. With VAR it was a foul," Amorim said.

"Then in the next game against Arsenal, who saved the penalty? Who saved the game? You don't remember the game but I remember the game and Altay was unbelievable in that game. I considered everything to put in one or another and I chose Altay…

"I am happy with the three goalkeepers."

Keane and Richards clash over Bayindir's role in Arsenal winner

Meanwhile, Sky Sports pundits Roy Keane and Micah Richards rowed over Bayindir's culpability for Arsenal's winner.

Former United midfielder Keane had no sympathy for the Turk, who appealed for a foul, with the Sky Sports pundit saying: "He has to come with violence, he's got to be aggressive, he's got to be almost saying to players, 'Come in here, I'm happy to deal with it'.

"But he's not strong enough. It's like schoolboy stuff. Don't look at the referee, take control of it."

Fellow pundit Richards, though, argued Bayindir should have been better protected by his defence, saying: "If you look at the balance between Saliba and (Mason) Mount, he's getting ragdolled everywhere.

"I just thought (Matthijs) De Ligt could have come inside and Mount could have gone outside. I agree with Roy, Bayindir should have done a lot better, but when you've got bodies in front of you…"

That prompted Keane to interject, with the pair raising their voices to the apparent amusement of fellow pundit Daniel Sturridge.

"The goalkeeper's on his heels, he should be on his toes. Saliba's doing very little to him," retorted Keane.

"The job of that player in that role is to protect the goalkeeper so he can come and punch it," hit back Richards. "There's a lot of chaos going on."

Keane had the final word, adding: "This is big boy stuff. You can't babysit a goalkeeper. He should go and play chess."

(c) Sky Sports 2025: Gary Neville says Man Utd need a goalkeeper, but would Emi Martinez or Gianluigi Donnarumma fit?